I criticize Obama frequently, and complain about mainstream media’s tendency to do what Jay Rosen calls he said, she said journalism. I’m often galled by NPR’s practice of the technique (particularly their refusal to call torture torture)
So I was please this morning to hear this report today on Morning Edition: Obama is requiring all hospitals who receive Medicare or Medicaid funding must allow same-sex couple visitation rights. And specifically, I was happy to hear Morning Edition’s journalists calling out conservative spinmeisters on their bullshit. They get both sides of the story, but do what reporters should do when one side of the story is blatantly wrong: they check the facts and provide context.
They call on J.P. Duffy, vice president for communications at the Family Research Council, to comment on the new memo:
Most hospitals, he said, have no restrictions on same-sex visitation.
But Dr. Jason Schneider, former president of the Gay and Lesbian Medical Association, said that unless a hospital has a formal policy allowing same-sex visitations, gay couples can run into trouble.
“One person in a hospital can make a huge difference — a security guard, a front desk clerk looking at a same-sex partner and saying, ‘You don’t have any right to go back there,’ ” Schneider said. “So I think this directive gives weight to the importance of recognizing the variety and the breadth of how people define families.”
It’s a move that Duffy of the Family Research Council calls “a big-government federal takeover of even the smallest details of the nation’s health care system.”
But this isn’t the first time a president has used Medicare funding to expand access to hospitals.
When President Johnson signed Medicare into law in 1965, many hospitals were racially segregated. That new law said hospitals that received federal Medicare dollars would have to integrate.
This is a commendable move by the Obama administration, and a good example of journalism providing context and fact checking instead of just “telling both sides of the story.” Bravo.
April 16, 2010 at 9:20 pm
Doesn’t say much about him that you have to reach this far to find something to commend him for…
April 16, 2010 at 9:21 pm
YES! Obama has just won my permanent respect. I don’t care what else he does or doesn’t do; this needed to happen. For any person who is turned away from visiting their significant other in the hospital, this is so much more than a “smallest detail”.
April 17, 2010 at 9:12 pm
Well, as a Gay man I feel that this is something a President SHOULD do, and that rather than giving Obama credit, all other Presidents since the 1980’s should receive a swift hard kick to the balls instead.
This needed to be law back in the 1980’s when a then unknown plague was killing homosexuals wholesale!